Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Electoral College Under Threat

 

Electoral College Under Threat

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would undermine Americans’ equal protection rights and create a constitutional crisis.

Joseph Burns, City Journal

With the 2026 election in the books, attention turns to what emboldened Democrats from state capitals to Capitol Hill will do with their newfound power. The press appears focused on hot topics like AI and affordability policies. But another item that could be on Democrats’ agenda—and has received almost no media attention—may have an even greater impact on the nation’s future.

For the better part of the last two decades, far-left activists have pushed the idea of abolishing the Electoral College, not through the obvious route of a constitutional amendment but instead through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC). The proposal attempts to undermine the Constitution by having states pledge their electors to the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of how the states voted.

The compact, however, would take effect only when enough states to represent a majority of the Electoral College agree to it. That’s what makes the results of the 2026 election so important.

At present, states equaling 222 electoral votes have agreed to the compact—just 48 electoral votes short. So far, only the country’s bluest states have embraced the agreement, and it seems doubtful that any solidly red states would join.

But the election may have changed the playing field. Democrats won complete control of the state legislature and governorship in at least six new states, five of which don’t currently belong to the NPVIC. Combined, those six states amount to 71 electoral votes, meaning that their newly Democrat-dominated state governments could try to put the NPVIC over the threshold and activate the compact.

While many rightfully believe that abolishing the Electoral College is bad policy, trying to kill it through a backdoor subversion of the Constitution is something more than bad policy—it is constitutionally dangerous.

The Constitution prohibits interstate compacts like the NPVIC without the approval of Congress. This provision—known as the Compact Clause—has been in the Constitution from the beginning. Even the Constitution’s predecessor, the Articles of Confederation, contained a similar interstate compact provision.

States are generally free to enter into agreements with other states. But the Constitution is explicit that these compacts are valid only with congressional approval, something that hasn’t happened with the NPVIC and is unlikely to happen under the new reality of divided government.

Some incorrectly maintain that congressional approval isn’t required for the NPVIC. But the courts have clearly held that when state agreements alter the balance of state power against federal power, or encroach on federal supremacy, congressional approval is necessary. The NPVIC does both. At a minimum, it renders the existing process for electing a president—in effect for over two centuries—a nullity. It also leaves nonparticipating states and state electors without a say in the election of a president. 

The Constitution’s Compact Clause isn’t the NPVIC’s only problem. The NPVIC also opens the door to infringing upon voters’ equal protection rights.

Under the NPVIC, the votes of residents in a compact state will count less than the votes of residents in other states. Because the state has committed to award electors based on the national popular vote, voters in a compact state will see the winner of their state’s electors determined by the choices of voters in every other state and the District of Columbia. Their own votes will—at best—play an incidental role in determining who the state chooses as its electors.

The NPVIC’s method for exiting the compact is likewise constitutionally dubious. While states in the compact are permitted to withdraw, they cannot do so within the six months preceding a presidential election.

The Constitution gives states tremendous latitude on how they select electors. But the NPVIC’s withdrawal terms undermine that constitutional provision by limiting a state’s ability to leave the compact and select an alternate method of selecting electors.

Should the compact be triggered, Americans will see an unprecedented flurry of litigation challenging the NPVIC leading up to the 2028 presidential election. Given its highly questionable constitutional grounding, the compact and its status in 2028 will make America’s political environment even more toxic than it already is.

In this scenario, while challenges wind through the courts, uncertainty about the election would affect voters, donors, and candidates of both parties. Will the election be the state-by-state, winner-take-all (except for Maine and Nebraska) contest we see quadrennially? Or, for the first time in American history, will the president be elected by a de facto national popular vote? That we won’t know the answer to these questions should give every American an uneasy feeling.

Well-intentioned Americans can have honest disagreements about the Electoral College and whether it should be preserved, reformed, or abolished. But no American, regardless of how he feels about the Electoral College, should want to see the 2028 presidential race thrown into turmoil because of a deceitful proposal to undermine the normal processes for constitutional change.

The NPVIC is closer than we know to becoming a reality. Democratic lawmakers in newly Democratic-controlled states should think long and hard before leading us down the road to a constitutional calamity.

Joseph Burns is a partner at Holtzman Vogel and former Deputy Director of Election Operations at the New York State Board of Elections.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

A Political Controlled Burn

 

A Political Controlled Burn

Sometimes you lose, but you can learn more from a loss or failure than from victory.

Allen West, Patriot Post

I remember when I was stationed at Ft. Riley near Manhattan, Kansas, my Mom did something she rarely, if ever, did. She took a plane ride out to visit me. Mom was not a big fan of airline travel. Back in the day, she preferred bus, train, or car. It was special to have Mom come out and spend time, especially to see her little granddaughter, Aubrey Elizabeth. Elizabeth was my Mom’s name. In those days, Manhattan, Kansas, did not have a thriving airport, so one had to do the two-and-a-half-hour drive down to Kansas City (MCI). Coming back to Manhattan, where we lived, the skies grew dark, and as we headed west from Topeka, we entered the wide-open Konza Prairie. Off in the distance, the night sky was illuminated. They were doing a controlled prairie burn. Mom, in her sweet Southern vernacular, kindly asked me if we were driving into hell.

I explained what I had learned during my years stationed there in Kansas. A controlled burn is a planned, purposeful use of fire in a specified area that, in the Konza Prairie, returns nutrients to the soil, stimulates growth, improves foraging for wildlife and reduces certain invasive plants and pest insects. It was not an uncontrolled wildfire but an intentional endeavor.

As it is, we are almost a week after the 2026 midterm elections, which I see as a politically controlled burn. Now, I doubt that the Republicans wanted to, shall I borrow a title from the Talking Heads, “Burn(ing) Down the House.” But as my Mom looked out and saw what she described as hell, it was a process that spurred on better growth, restored nutrients, and safeguarded against invasive species. No, I am not in any way, shape, or form in a panic or worry mode about Tuesday, 3 November 2026. Matter of fact, I remember the midterm election of November 2006. I was in Kandahar, Afghanistan, then. The Republicans got pummeled. George Bush had to contend with Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid in his final two years. Then, in 2008, Barack Hussein Obama came to town, and the leftists expanded their majorities in the House and Senate. Then, in Obama’s first midterm election, November 2010, he got pummeled and lost 63 seats in the House, including yours truly. Quite amazing: in four years, from Kandahar, Afghanistan, to Capitol Hill. And we know that Obama would lose the Senate in 2014.

I do not have time to toss about in sackcloth and dirt, seeking out self-pity and despair. What we should do is recognize this moment and learn from it, just as our American Army learned from the debacle of 1943 in North Africa at Kasserine Pass. Here are several critical takeaways.

First and foremost, there has to be message discipline, and everyone needs to be on the same policy agenda. For this midterm election, the Trump administration should have been focused on the issues the American people are discussing in their homes: the economy, domestic security, border security, and quality educational opportunities. You have to think about what Americans deal with every day and seek policies to alleviate those issues. And there has to be constant communication with the people. That means weekly “fireside chats,” but now leverage social media technology. I get tired of people complaining to me that the media lies. Then pummel the media with the truth, and go directly to the people. And that is where message discipline comes in: everyone together articulating the same points and accomplishments. Ya know, that is something leftists do very well, as students of Nazi Minister of Propaganda Joseph Goebbels: “If you tell a lie often enough, over and over, it will eventually be taken as truth.” You can only beat that by telling the truth, over and over.

Next, I came on active duty in the Army a week after the Beirut barracks bombing of 23 October 1983. I despise the country that is the number-one sponsor of Islamic terrorism. If the decision to engage Iran was to be made, then yes, you degrade its capability and capacity to adversely affect the world and the region. I wrote an article for Townhall on 25 May 2026 titled “The Art of War, not the Deal.” Deals are business transactions. You don’t make a deal with folks who want you dead. If you embark on a combat operation, you had best have a phased plan of execution across the three levels of operations: strategic, operational, and tactical. You cannot do strategic military policy on a social media platform. Nor can you say one day we will obliterate, and the next day we will make a deal, negotiate, or make a memorandum of agreement. And let’s be honest, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff don’t have a steely-eyed killer look, which is what enemies understand and respect. If you’re gonna fight, then fight. America has struggled with half-measure warfare for far too long, and this Iranian endeavor is another chapter in that discouraging book.

Let’s do better with candidate selection. America needs statesmen and women. America needs principled constitutional conservatives who are impeccable communicators and possess a warrior spirit. This country is in a seminal battle of ideals, an ideological civil war, that we can ill afford to lose. The lines of this battle have been established, and there is no place for cowards, summer soldiers, and sunshine patriots. Republicans failed to deliver, especially on the SAVE America Act. In my home of Texas, Republicans aligned themselves with Democrats who chose the Speaker of the Texas House. The era of the Bush-Rove cabal of the GOP establishment is over. But also, the era of populism is coming to an end. The only way to defeat the unholy alliance of Marxism/Islamism in America is a rededication to our founding principles, values, and ideals. America needs more men and women who know our Declaration of Independence, our Constitution, our history, and proudly express it to the people and stand with conviction, not being how-the-wind-blows type people.

Sometimes you lose, but you can learn more from a loss or failure than from victory. The leftists and their Islamist allies are going to gloat, overplay their hand, and go down the hill way over their skis. The question is, who will be there for the American people to turn to, not just in the next political cycle, but for decades to come. After the utter debacle at Kasserine Pass, General Eisenhower made the decision to relieve the previous corps commander and bring in a new fella, named General George S. Patton.

America, now is not the time for moaning and groaning. It is the time to “Ruck Up” and let’s get at it. There’s a new generation awaiting their moment to lead. Let’s find them, teach, coach, mentor, and cultivate them, and begin the process of restoring this Constitutional Republic.

The fight is on!

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Stephen Miller time in the Trump admin

 

It’s Stephen Miller time in the Trump admin!

The threatened media and Dems are already spreading misinformation

 Michael Goodwin, California Post

There’s bad press, and then there’s the coverage of Stephen Miller’s promotion.

In making Miller his new chief of staff, President Trump unleashed an avalanche of pent-up resentment toward his new top aide.

The cruelest cut came from Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, the Democrats’ House leader who wants to be the next speaker.

He said his team would not work with Miller, whom he labeled a “stone cold racist.”

The outrageous slander said more about the embattled Jeffries than it does Miller.

Still, there is no arguing with the reasonable view that the new White House chief’s style is not one that ­endears.

Miller is whip smart and has a voluminous knowledge of government, laws and court precedents on immigration, all of which he routinely unloads on questioners in a machine-gun cadence.

His demeanor often conveys contempt and his habit of talking down to people has made him a favorite whipping boy for Dems and their media handmaidens.

Don still in charge

Part of that reaction stems from the fact that Miller is the ultimate Trump loyalist and has been with the president since the 2016 campaign.

As far back as his college days at Duke, Miller had a laser-like focus on immigration, which was long before Trump entered politics.

As such, Miller’s promotion from policy deputy to former chief of staff Susie Wiles to her replacement seems almost inevitable.

To judge from the river of bile flowing his way, detractors assume Miller will usurp all of Trump’s responsibility to set the agenda, and will be the only White House contact for the Dem congressional majority.

As The New York Times put it in a bizarre front-page headline, “Miller pursues agenda voters have rejected.”

Memo to the Gray Lady: Trump will remain president for the next two years, and the Dem Congress will not control the government.

Some of the anti-Miller hyperbole reflects how the president’s harshest critics tend to see the aide as a reflection of what they regard as Trump’s inner darkness.

Indeed, Trump himself has admitted agent mistakes in a few cases that involved shootings and promises to dial back aggressive actions.

Yet it is only fair to see Miller in other crucial ways because the personal dislike for him overshadows three key points.

First, he has never been a policy maker, and while he has served as an adviser of Trump’s immigration stances, he doesn’t make the policy he is called upon to explain and defend.

Second, it is critical to remember that Trump’s consistent hard-line on immigration is a major reason why he was first elected in 2016, and again in 2024.

In both cases voters, among other things, wanted a sharp change from years of lax border enforcement.

Inherited disaster

The third point is that the immigration disaster Trump inherited in his second term was not seen as crucial by Dems or the lefty media, and still isn’t.

They supported Joe Biden’s open-border policy, which was a total disaster.

The numbers alone remain staggering.

Biden’s decision to open the gates to 12 million or more illegals, without any assessment of who they were and how they would support themselves created an unprecedented problem that remains unsolved.

The 12 million or more entries dwarfs all historical comparisons.

A prior era of mass migration, the 30-year period from 1890 to 1920, saw about 18 million immigrants come to America.

To think that anywhere near those numbers could be seamlessly absorbed in a four-year term a century later is insane.

In fact, it’s not clear even Biden believed the influx could be managed.

Although he appeared to be concerned about the policy he supposedly had approved, his response was to make his incompetent vice president, Kamala Harris, the border czar.

The president said nothing as she dodged the assignment after a few fumbles.

Biden’s director of Homeland Security, Alejandro Mayorkas, consistently claimed to Congress that the border was safe and secure, even as drugs and migrants flowed in like a river.

For his lies and inaction, Mayorkas was impeached by a divided House of Representatives on charges that accused him of “willful and systemic refusal to comply with the law,” but the move was rejected by the Senate.

Exhibit A: NYC

Meanwhile, no Dem official in any blue state complained about the endless surge of unemployed and often unemployable men showing up in their cities.

Take New York’s then mayor, Eric Adams, who threw open Gotham’s doors to all comers.

His only complaint was to call Texas Republicans racists because they were sending buses full of migrants to New York and other blue cities.

The Republicans had a clear purpose — to share the pain and cost so those mayors would lobby Biden to close the border.

Adams’ only demand even as Midtown Manhattan was flooded was that Albany and Washington help fund his extravagant Welcome Wagon, which included free housing, food, transportation, education and medical care.

According to estimates, the city and state spent a combined $15 billion over a four-year period on the illegal newcomers — and many expenses are ongoing.

In his 2024 campaign, Trump repeatedly targeted ballooning costs, the ignorance about who the newcomers were, and cases of violent crime and murders committed by illegals.

There was no serious counterargument, just the Dems’ usual knee-jerk charges of racism and xenophobia, all of which were amplified by left-wing media.

Those outlets embraced the cases of high-profile illegal immigrants Trump tried to deport.

A telling example involved Kilmar Abrego Garcia, which most of the media identified as simply a “Maryland man” who was “wrongly deported.”

In fact, he was in the US illegally, and authorities believed he was a member of the deadly MS-13 gang, a human trafficker, and wife-beater.

Similarly, attempts to deport foreign students who engaged in anti-Israel protests and riots were met with hysteria.

Back to the future

Trump, in a 2023 campaign speech, laid out what his policies would be and cited the Hamas invasion of Israel that year.

He declared that “we’ll terminate the visas of all of those Hamas sympathizers, and we’ll get them off our college campuses, out of our cities and get them the hell out of our country.”

The Times countered those promises with a hysteria of its own making.

In a reflection of the paper’s anti-Trump agenda, a headline on a column by radical writer Michelle Goldberg declared that the Mahmoud Khalil case “Is the Greatest Threat to Free Speech Since the Red Scare.”

The approach allowed little or no coverage of cases where illegal migrants were charged with murders, rapes and other horrific crimes.

Now that Miller is Trump’s top gun and Dems control Congress, what’s old will be new again.

Don’t be shocked when the energized left demands open borders.

Friday, October 09, 2026

Genocide Hypocrites

Genocide Hypocrites

Victor Davis Hanson, Jewish World Review

On October 7, 2023, Hamas killers slaughtered 1,200 people, more than two-thirds of them civilians, inside Israel. For the ensuing three weeks, they refused Israel’s demands to turn over the 251 hostages and to surrender the architects of the massacre. No matter — within a day of the attacks, when Hamas gunmen were still fighting Israeli troops on Israeli soil, the American Left was already screaming "genocide!"

They did not mean Hamas’s intended genocide of Jews, a foretaste of which was seen when it launched a surprise invasion force of more than 4,000 terrorists some 15 miles into Israel. The killers were accompanied by some 2,000 "innocent" Gazan "civilians." All were bent on looting, murder, rape, torture, and hostage-taking of the defenseless.

Nor did the "genocide" chorus refer to the more than 13,000 rockets, missiles, and drones launched from Gaza after October 7 that predominantly targeted Israeli civilian neighborhoods.

What was most surreal about the charges of "genocide" against Israel — along with all the other slurs of "settler-colonialism," "apartheid," "occupation," "war crimes" — was that they so often came from elite first- and second-generation Middle Eastern immigrants to America. Yet these prominent American accusers have remained silent about whether their lurid accusations might far better reflect the sordid histories of their own homelands.

Take the Turkish-American anchor baby Hasan Piker, the millionaire podcaster who has dual citizenship and grew up in Turkey. Piker has gained celebrity as the socialist heartthrob who is the brain of the new Democratic/Socialist/Islamist alliance. Besides his antisemitic rants, he has declared that "America deserved 9/11" and "Oh God, I f-ing hate America so much."

Yet the outspoken Piker has only once in passing mentioned Turkey’s 1974 invasion and the half-century-long occupation of nearly 40 percent of Cyprus.

Nor did Piker, who damns the creation of Israel in 1948, ever say a word about the Turkish torching of the historic Greek-majority Ionian city of Smyrna in 1922, in which tens of thousands of civilians were incinerated.

Given Piker’s supposedly vast historical recall and outspoken human rights advocacy, one would at least expect him to be sensitive to the horror of Turkey’s Armenian genocide, in which Turkish troops slaughtered more than one million civilians, and for which the Turkish government still denies any culpability. But when once challenged by Armenian-Americans, he dismissed them, saying flippantly, "It’s more fun to enrage you."

And the pattern goes beyond mere podcasters.

Representative Ilhan Omar, a first-generation immigrant from Somalia, also brays loudly about supposed Israeli war crimes. Omar spouts "genocide" and "apartheid" in her frequently antisemitic rants. She has also labeled her adopted nation as "one of the worst countries" in the world.

But Omar is the daughter of a well-known colonel in the truly genocidal army of Somali dictator Siad Barre. The latter waged a decade-long war of extermination against the rival Isaaq clan that opposed Barre’s 21-year-long dictatorship. Estimates of the Barre regime’s murderous toll range from 50,000 to 200,000 killed, mostly civilians. Few in Omar’s politically active Somali immigrant community ever concede that many fled Somalia to America only when Barre’s two-decade reign of terror was finally overthrown, and they feared retaliation from his victims.

Of course, the nation’s biggest elected leftist rising star has also joined in.

Zohran Mamdani, mayor of New York City, employs the same tired anti-Israeli and anti-American verbiage. Yet he went further than other antisemites when he launched grandstanding threats to jail Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu any time the latter visited New York to address the United Nations.

For America’s 250th birthday, Mamdani’s July 3 "commemorative" address blasted American "monopolies that dominate every industry," federal agents supposedly "terrorizing our streets," and a country where we "sell our elections to the highest bidder." The calumny was odd coming from a dual citizen of the police state of Uganda, where there are no real elections but lots of Indian "monopolies."

Indeed, Mamdani himself better fits his own charges of "settler-colonist" and "apartheid." His Indian community in Uganda comprises less than 0.1% of the population. But somehow it still accounts for over 60% of Uganda’s GDP. It was implanted there by 19th-century British imperialists as a "settler-colonial" community to help control the indigenous black population.

In short, we should remind these privileged ingrates — regardless of what corner of the world they hail from — to look inward before they blast their adopted country and not to project the sins of their own homelands upon either Israel or America.

Victor Davis Hanson is the Martin and Illie Anderson Senior Fellow in Residence in Classics and Military History at the Hoover Institution, a professor of classics emeritus at California State University at Fresno, and a nationally syndicated columnist for Tribune Media Services. 

Monday, September 28, 2026

Strange Racist, Nikole Hannah-Jones

 


The strange racial solidarity of Nikole Hannah-Jones

Rich Lowry, Jewish World Review

The New York Times writer Nikole Hannah-Jones thought she was making her educational choices to favor the interests of black people, and she was -- just the wrong ones.

In a long essay for The New York Times Magazine, the radical African American journalist writes about how her decision to send her daughter to dreadful New York City public schools for ideological reasons ended in tears.

Jones, who achieved notoriety as the lead editor of the paper's 1619 Project, believed that putting her daughter in rotten elementary and middle schools would strike a blow for racial equity.

In her view, it's unfair that so many black kids are trapped in underperforming New York City schools, and if she trapped her own daughter in them, she and her husband -- with their superior wherewithal -- could make the schools better for everyone.

What started as a project motivated by a savior complex ended as essentially an episode of educational Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

Her bright young daughter fell far behind where she could have been academically.

Most parents who are paying attention and who have the means would immediately get a kid out of a school where there are fights during the lunch period, where there is no homework, where the principal and teachers are routinely absent, and where school work isn't graded -- but Nikole Hannah-Jones persisted.

By the time her daughter was old enough to realize what was going on and force her mother to let her apply to better high schools, she didn't know algebra despite getting excellent grades in math at the subpar schools.

Hannah-Jones should be furious at the adults who failed her daughter so abysmally, but she's, in effect, still on their side by portraying school choice as a racist scam and complaining about a lack of resources.

The New York City officials, administrators, principals and teachers who are blighting the futures of young people aren't white supremacists; by and large, they agree with Nikole Hannah-Jones politically and many of them are African American.

You can either be with them, and their narrow interest in protecting the school system from serious challenges, or with the kids.

Hannah-Jones is in a version of the same conundrum as the Black Lives Matter activists who believed it was "anti-racist" to agitate against the police. Then, when they got their way and the police stepped back, more black people were killed.

Here it is supposedly "anti-racist" to keep everyone in disorderly, incompetent public schools -- and the victims are black children who have no idea of how little they've learned until it's too late.

This is a strange form of racial solidarity.

There is no doubt that schools have a tougher job when they have a high population of disadvantaged students. But the problem is not funding, as Hannah-Jones suggests. Studies from the centrist Brookings Institution note both that high-poverty, non-white districts spend more per pupil than lower-poverty districts, and that higher spending doesn't ensure better results.

The Success Academy charter schools in New York City have shown that disadvantaged kids can thrive when there's an old-fashioned mix of high expectations, strict discipline and rigorous instruction -- in other words, what the traditional public schools, mired in a self-interested, unaccountable bureaucracy, can't deliver.

When she sent her daughter to failing schools, Nikole Hannah-Jones imagined herself acting in the tradition of pioneering parents during the civil rights movement who sent their children through their mobs to integrate whites-only schools. Those parents desperately wanted a better education for their kids, though, whereas Hannah-Jones fed her daughter into terrible public schools in the forlorn hope that maybe she'd be OK. If not, at least Hannah-Jones had steered her clear of competitive schools with lots of white and Asian kids.

That, of course, was a perverse priority. The famous line is that a neoconservative is a liberal mugged by reality. The New York City public schools mugged Nikole Hannah-Jones, and yet she still doesn't want to press charges.


Saturday, September 26, 2026

SUPREMES SIDE WITH TRUMP

 

SUPREMES SIDE WITH TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IN VOTING CASE

John Hinderacker, Powerline

Yesterday, the Supreme Court issued a per curiam order staying a district court order that had blocked the Trump administration from implementing an election security measure. The case is Department of Homeland Security v. League of Women Voters. (As always, I encourage our readers to read the Court’s opinions for themselves. They are not impenetrable, and you don’t have to be a lawyer to follow them.)

The program in question arose from an executive order by President Trump that expanded the scope of the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements program, enacted in 1986. Historically, that program has provided an avenue for federal, state, and local government agencies to verify the citizenship and immigration status of noncitizens applying for public benefits. Trump expanded the program by executive order last year, directing the Department of Homeland Security to put systems in place to allow state and local officials to verify the citizenship status of registered voters or persons registering to vote, and directing the Social Security Administration to make its records available to DHS for that purpose.

The Court described the impact of Trump’s executive order:

The modified program differed from the original in two key respects. First, it incorporated checks against additional records—including social security numbers (SSNs)—maintained by SSA. Second, it allowed state and local authorities to conduct bulk searches of multiple individuals at once.

The issue in the case was whether Trump’s order violated privacy provisions of the Social Security Act or the Privacy Act of 1974. The Court’s 6-3 majority held that Trump’s order was authorized by the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996:

The first, section 1373(a), provides:

“Notwithstanding any other provision of Federal, State, or local law, a Federal, State, or local government entity or official may not prohibit, or in any way restrict, any government entity or official from sending to, or receiving from, the [DHS] information regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual.”

Like so many recent cases, this one came to the Court in a preliminary stage, so the Court held that the administration is likely to ultimately prevail on the merits, stayed the anti-Trump order that had been issued by the district court, and sent the case back to the district court for further proceedings.

The Court’s decision received quite a bit of attention, perhaps out of proportion to its practical import. Here are a few observations about it:

District court judges loyal to the Democratic Party have tried to interfere with virtually everything the Trump administration does, especially when it relates to illegal immigration. It is easy for plaintiffs recruited by the Democratic Party or other left-wing groups to judge-shop to get their cases in front of such judges.

These Democratic Party judges consistently enter orders barring the administration from implementing the policy in question. The cases then reach the appellate courts, sometimes the Supreme Court, in that posture. The Trump administration has won most of these cases, but the purpose of delay is always achieved, to some degree. The Supreme Court has had no choice but to get involved, lest partisan judges completely hamstring the administration with bogus legal rulings.

This case has gotten quite a bit of attention, but I don’t think it will have much impact, at least as regards the 2026 elections. This is true for two reasons, one of which was acknowledged in the Court’s per curiam opinion:

The plaintiff organizations argue that the Federal Government will not suffer irreparable harm because federal law currently prohibits state and local election authorities from clearing their voter rolls in the weeks leading up to federal elections. The organizations point to the National Voter Registration Act (NVRA), 52 U. S. C. §20507(c)(2)(A), which provides that “[a] State shall complete, not later than 90 days prior to the date of a primary or general election for Federal office, any program the purpose of which is to systematically remove the names of ineligible voters from the official lists of eligible voters.”2 To be sure, that moratorium limits the potential impact of staying the District Court’s order in this case. Still, all agree that the order prevents the Federal Government from using the modified SAVE program to conduct individualized inquiries, which are permitted under federal law during this period. The District Court’s order thus inhibits the Federal Government’s efforts to assist state and local agencies in the proper administration of the midterm elections.

The second reason why the order won’t have much impact is that the modified SAVE system simply authorizes federal agencies to cooperate with state and local agencies who seek assistance in verifying the citizenship status of voters. But voter fraud occurs mostly in blue states and localities, and it happens because government authorities in those states (Democrats) want it to happen. So I doubt there will be many requests coming in from the jurisdictions where most fraud occurs.

Finally, the Supreme Court’s three political justices–Kagan, Sotomayor and Jackson–dissented from the per curiam opinion. This is a consistent pattern, pretty much every time any interest of the Democratic Party is at stake. In this case, as in quite a few others, the dissent was written by Justice Jackson. To be fair, however, and contrary to her reputation, Jackson’s dissent in this case is not stupid. I don’t think it is ultimately persuasive, but she makes a decent argument, enabled by the fact that the multiple statutes at issue in this case are drafted, as is generally the case, with less than mathematical precision.

Sunday, August 02, 2026

Fauci and the great Covid cover-up

 

Fauci and the great Covid cover-up

Did scientists mislead the world about the origins of the pandemic?

Matt Ridley, Spiked-online

This week, Republican senator Rand Paul subpoenaed Dr Anthony Fauci – the Covid pandemic’s rockstar medic (and long-serving bureaucrat). He was to appear before Paul’s Senate hearing for a showdown about the origin of the Covid pandemic. In the run-up to the hearing, Paul released more than 1,000 pages of emails and Slack messages sent by Fauci and his associates before and during the pandemic, including an astonishing diary that Fauci had kept during the critical years of 2019 to 2022.

But at the hearing, Fauci invoked the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination despite having been pardoned by then US president Joe Biden. So we learned nothing new from the Senate hearing. Nevertheless, the document dump has deepened the evidence of rank duplicity by Fauci and his associates. The people who spent most of 2020-2022 insisting a lab leak could not possibly have happened thought, in private, that it possibly had.

They lied to us. There is now little doubt that, like Chernobyl, Bhopal and 9/11, the pandemic was manmade. And it killed 100 times as many people as those three disasters put together. Yet a bunch of people with power and influence did their utmost to bury the truth about the cause.

For a long time, I disagreed with the focus on Fauci. It took the spotlight off the Wuhan Institute of Virology and the Chinese researchers working there – in Wuhan, the very city where Covid first emerged. They were engaged in ‘gain of function’ research, editing the genomic sequence of virus samples so as to make them much more infectious. These idiotic experiments almost certainly caused the outbreak and those carrying them out refused to share information about them. But I have to admit that the latest facts about Fauci are shocking.

This is a man who was for a time the highest paid federal employee, retiring on a pension of $400,000 a year. He ran the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) for an astonishing 38 years, one year longer than J Edgar Hoover lasted as the untouchable head of the FBI.

Like Hoover, power and status went to Fauci’s head. At the height of the pandemic his diary shows him obsessed with his own celebrity. Here’s what he wrote on 21 May 2020: ‘Deaths 9,800… It is not hyperbole to say that today I am the most famous and talked-about person in the country and one of the most recognisable people in the world.’ On another occasion he writes, ‘press still hot and heavy about me’. After meeting a celebrity he boasts that ‘one person said that Tyra [Banks] was sexy, but I was even more sexy than she was’.

Worse, at a time of great emergency, Fauci used federal colleagues to solicit scientists – funded by his agency – to nominate him for eight large cash awards, totalling over $1million. I paraphrase, but this example is real: Dear Barton Haynes, Here’s $282million for your research. Now, would you like to nominate me for a $900,000 award? My assistant will write the necessary prose for you. Yours, Tony. Haynes did as he was told. ‘You bet’, he wrote.

That is the public-sector version of insider trading.

But nauseating narcissism and gobsmacking greed (and using private email addresses for government business) do not in themselves cause or cover up pandemics. The far greater sin was deliberately misleading the world about the origin of Covid-19. And there in black and white on 26 January 2020 in his diary is Fauci’s line about the Wuhan seafood market, which many claimed was the origin of Covid: ‘Now we know the market was not the source, it was the amplifier.’

Yet, a week later, he convened a group of 12 scientists, most of whom thought it possible, perhaps even probable, that the virus had been engineered in a laboratory, to discuss their concerns. He then tasked four of the fairly junior ones in the meeting (a fifth author joined later), some of whom depended on grants from his agency, to write a paper, ‘The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2’. This paper outright dismissed the possibility of a lab leak as the origin of Covid. He and Jeremy Farrar, the then director of the Wellcome Trust, edited and promoted the publication of that paper. Fauci then disguised his own role in doing so, and spoke about it from the podium of the White House as if he had nothing to do with it.

Before and after they wrote the paper its authors all thought a lab leak was possible, perhaps even likely, as their private messages have repeatedly confirmed. Here’s what the lead author, Kristian Andersen, said the day after the meeting:

‘The main issue is that accidental escape is in fact highly likely – it’s not some fringe theory. I absolutely agree that we can’t prove one way or the other, but we never will be able to – however, that doesn’t mean that by default the data [are] currently much more suggestive of a natural origin as opposed to [for example] passage. It is not – the furin cleavage site is very hard to explain.’

(Andersen’s concern about the furin cleavage site is important to note. Researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology are known to have planned to insert a furin cleavage site into the spike gene of a SARS-related virus, in order to increase infectivity in human beings but not bats. All you really need to know about furin cleavage sites is that Covid is the first and only SARS-related virus, out of many hundreds that have been described, ever to show up with a furin cleavage site in its spike gene.)

And here’s what Andrew Rambaut, of Edinburgh University, said about Covid’s origins: ‘I literally swivel day by day thinking it is a lab escape or natural.’

Yet both Andersen and Rambaut put their names to a paper that categorically ruled out a laboratory origin. When ‘The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2′ shot up the scientific-impact charts, Rambaut crowed: ‘Top! Fuck me.’ And Andersen replied: ‘We RUUUUUUULE. That’s tenure secured, right there.’ Fauci’s agency finalised a $8.9million grant to Andersen’s lab, and co-author Bob Garry’s lab, shortly after.

Thereafter Fauci vilified anybody who even raised the possibility of a lab leak. It worked. Look at the way the media fell into line following that paper’s publication: ‘Scientists debunk lab-accident theory of pandemic emergence’, said National Public Radio. ‘Sorry, conspiracy theorists. Study concludes Covid-19 “is not a laboratory construct”’, said ABC News. ‘Fact check: Did the coronavirus originate in a Chinese laboratory?… We rate this claim FALSE’, claimed USA Today. ‘Anthony Fauci just crushed Donald Trump’s theory on the origins of the coronavirus’, said CNN.

Over here, Ian Birrell at the Daily Mail and Sarah Knapton at the Telegraph were honourable exceptions to this lemming rush. The rest of the media was supine. Today, the evidence for a natural source of the virus is zero. Researchers have found not a single infected animal in any market, nor any person who caught Covid from an animal. The evidence for the lab is overwhelming: we know they were doing precisely the right kind of experiment on precisely the right strain of virus at precisely the right time in precisely the right city and in precisely the wrong biosafety conditions.

What was Fauci’s motive for misleading the world? That is clear as a bell: he had spent decades championing the idea that gain-of-function research on risky viruses was a good idea, even as others expressed serious doubts. Here is what his nemesis, Richard Ebright of Rutgers University, had to say about his agenda in 2005: ‘A majority of the nation’s top microbiologists – the very group that the Bush administration is counting on to carry out its biodefence-research agenda – dispute the premises and implementation of the biodefence spending.’ In Fauci’s diary he calls Ebright ‘preposterous’ and a ‘villain’.

Specifically, Fauci’s NIAID funded the work on coronaviruses, first at the University of North Carolina, and then in Wuhan. Fauci himself knew this by 23 January 2020, when an email was sent with the following subject: ‘Urgent for Dr Fauci: China’s lab for studying SARS and Ebola is in Wuhan, the outbreak’s centre’, which discussed the grant NIAID had given the intermediary body, EcoHealth Alliance, to fund the work in Wuhan.

So Fauci knew from then onwards that if a lab leak looked plausible, his own role in godfathering the research would come out. He had to keep a lid on it for a few weeks until the outbreak petered out. Only it did not peter out. It turned into a three-year ordeal that killed 20million people and turned the world economy upside down. Naturally, people were keen to investigate how this happened.

To give one detailed example of the way we were all misled over a global disaster, consider the case of Ralph Baric – a scientist funded by Fauci, but who Fauci claimed he hardly knew. In the new dump of documents, there are key revelations about the role of this University of North Carolina scientist who developed fiendishly clever techniques for swapping genes between coronaviruses and taught the Chinese scientiststo do it.

One of the handful of feeble arguments against a lab-leak origin of Covid was that the virus that causes it was not a perfect fit for human receptors: if they were designing it to infect human cells then they would have done it better. It is not much of an argument but the ‘Proximal Origin’ paper placed a lot of weight on it. However, Baric knew by 2019 that making an imperfect match was actually the smart thing to do. If the fit is too good, the virus gets stuck and is less infectious. But he insisted to congressional investigators he never told his Chinese colleagues that.

Yet what does the independent sleuth Gilles Demaneuf find in Baric’s own notes for a talk he gave at a conference in Harbin in China in January 2019? ‘Creating a virus that is super-adapted to a particular host can actually result in an attenuation of virulence, if the virus interacts overly strongly with a cellular receptor.’ Whoops – it looks like he did coach the Chinese researchers on this step after all.

It is a weird experience reading the messages these scientists exchanged during the pandemic. They sent up to 50 messages a day to each other during busy periods – did they have time to do, er, science? They use the f-word repeatedly – I am no prude but who needs to do that in exchanges with colleagues? And they are obsessed with ‘discrediting’ (rather than rebutting) anybody who even toyed with a theory they themselves thought ‘friggin likely’. They call me a ‘complete idiot’ and say of my brilliant young co-author, Alina Chan: ‘We need to push hard to discredit people like Alina as conspiracy theorists.’

Far more serious, however, is the way they try to prevent information coming out. British scientist Peter Daszak was the intermediary whose EcoHealth Alliance shovelled American taxpayer funds to the Chinese laboratory that did the dangerous experiments. Here he is coaching his Chinese colleagues on how to be non-transparent, warning Shi Zhengli of the Wuhan Institute of Virology not to respond to very polite and reasonable requests from a very distinguished American scientist, Jesse Bloom, for detailed information about certain experiments:

‘Dear Zhengli,

I strongly recommend you don’t answer more questions from Jesse Bloom. The questions may seem harmless, like he is trying to find out more about basic information, but his goals are to continue attacking you, the WIV, and our collaboration. He has already asked me about the RaTG13 information separately, and I responded with a single sentence to tell him the sequence is incomplete at the end of the genome. In other words he already knew the answer but wrote to you separately anyway, I believe he is trying to see if one of us says a different response so he can accuse us of lying

With someone like this, if you give home [sic] more than a short response, he will use the information against you. He has done this with us in the past by making public statements about things we’ve said in emails to him and criticising us.’

Think about this for a second. Millions of people are dying; finding out why should be a priority. But a British ‘grantrepreneur’ who has done very nicely out of supporting very risky and foolish experiments wants a citizen of a communist country not to help a scientist find out more.

The likes of Daszak and especially Anthony Fauci still have serious questions to answer.


Matt Ridley is a science writer and co-author of Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19, with Alina Chan.